Political Philosophy / U.S. Constitution

The Trouble With Constitutional Tribbles

Marc Clair 9/18/2012

When I can’t think of a blog post title, my first rule of thumb is to reference a classic Star Trek episode. This of course leads in turn to getting an excuse to post a hilarious screen cap from that classic episode. Having your own website is fun!

It seems the Lions of Liberty engine is running just a tick slow this week, celebrating our birthday a day late and now just getting around to Constitution Day a day late as well.  I guess that’s what old age will do to ya.

I do sometimes find odd the reverence many libertarians have for the Constitution.  Often we hear arguments like “Well it’s in the Constitution” to make an argument for, say, gold and silver as legal tender for example.  This can cause problems however as it is often refuted by a typical progressive response of “well that thing was written 200 years ago, the world doesn’t work that way now” or something to that effect.  Of course, supporters of sound money know that this is a silly argument, but they set themselves up for it when using the Constitution to push their point.  That’s because, ultimately, the Constitution really is “just a goddamn piece of paper”.

There certainly are many good ideas in the Constitution, such as yes, gold and silver as currency as well as the protections listed in the Bill of Rights.  But we certainly can’t ignore all the bad things about the Constitution.  For starters, it created the federal government where there originally had been 13 largely independent States under the Articles of Confederation.  It also explicitly gave that same federal government the power to tax and to form a “standing army”.  And we can’t ignore that slavery is recognized in the Constitution, with Congress prohibited from limiting the States ability to import slaves as well as the infamous “Three-Fifths Compromise”, which resulted in slaves counting as “3/5th” of a person for census purposes.

LewRockwell.com blogger Lawrence Vance recently noted 5 other points about the Constitution:

1. The Constitution was violated soon after it was adopted.

2. The so-called Civil War destroyed the Constitution.

3. The Constitution has failed to limit the federal government.

4. Those who talk the most about the Constitution (Republicans) violate it every chance they get.

5. The Constitution only means what the Supreme Court says it means. The Antifederalists were right and right again.

When Vance mentions the “Anti-Federalists” he is referring to those who were opposing the creation of this central Constitutional government because of concerns that, regardless of limits spelled out in the document, a strong central government was bound to grow to an unlimited size until it eventually was worse than the government they had rebelled against.  It’s hard to look around today and not think that maybe, just maaaaaaybe, they might have been on to something.

These problems with the Constitution can come back to bite you when using it as the sole basis of making an argument for something.  Using gold and silver as currency is a great idea, but not because it is in the Constitution. Using gold and silver as currency is a good idea because sound money is essential to capital growth in a free economy.  And then one can go on to make all the arguments for sound money and make a case against central banking. .

Once you have made this argument, it is then appropriate to say something to the effect of “and that’s why the writers of the Constitution inserted the clause about gold and silver” to emphasize the point.  It is important to base the “why” of an argument on a deeply held principle or a sound economic theory.  So arm yourself with knowledge.  Study under some of the great Austrian economists at the Mises Academy.  Learn real history and economics at Tom Woods’ Liberty Classroom.  Or just study check on some of the sites in our “Liberty Friends” section.

In whatever way you do it, be prepared for the next time you encounter a Big Government Zombie.

Read the original post here:  http://lionsofliberty.com/2012/09/18/the-trouble-with-constitutional-tribbles/

Visit Lions of Liberty Blog http://lionsofliberty.com/


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s